Improve Oversight of Fertilizer Plants
Thursday, April 25, 2013
Thursday, April 25, 2013
This week on April 17th, the
article “Improve Oversight of Fertilizer Plant" appearing in the Austin American
Statesman definitely drew my attention, like many other people
who wanted to know about the big tragedy overwhelming the
media. We mourn the miserable tragedy that killed 14 people,
including 10 volunteer firefighters in West, Texas. The
accident, the explosion of the fertilizer plant, left us in shock. It
is too much sadness to describe with any words. While I read this article, I
really could understand why such a big tragedy happened, as the author gave
a lot of thorough information.
I agree that the explosion might not have been totally
preventable, but there must be greater regulation imposed on dangerous chemical
storage plants in our state. Perry wants to promote new businesses moving to
Texas while relaxing the regulations on industry, but the cost is too
great for our residents. This plant has been cited numerous times in the
past for various violations, and yet was allowed to keep operating without any
serious penalties or fines. We must do more to protect our citizens from
these types of potentially dangerous plants operating in our state.
If we don't, it's not a matter of "if" another explosion
could occur, but "when" the next one will happen. West is not
the first town in Texas to be devastated by a massive explosion, as Texas City
was rocked by the worst industrial accident in American history over fifty
years ago like the author mentioned.
Growth at "all cost" is not worth the lives of innocent citizens.
The author argues that “the direct cause of the explosion was
a fire that heated tons of ammonium nitrate to the point of
deadly detonation,” but the original problem came from a “muddled and fractured"
state and federal regulatory system which allowed the conditions that
led to the explosion. The one example he gives make us, the readers,
extremely upset; the last year the company stored 270 tons of
ammonia nitrate, significantly more than legally allowed to be stored
without report. He says that “Any amount of ammonium nitrate over 400 pounds is
supposed to be reported to the US Department.” However, “the West plant did not
notify the department. It was over 1,350 times the maximum allowed before
notification is required.”
He also mentions, “Further, the department relies on
self-reporting, and it doesn’t have enough money or inspectors to carry out
inspection of the 600 fertilizer depots and plants.” Legal regulations and
citations aren’t effective when there aren’t enough inspectors to do the work.
He gives information that “the insurance Council of Texas estimates damages
will reach $100 million.” His information is enough to understand the federal
regulatory system is weak. However, I really wonder, what kind of federal
regulations are enforced in Texas? If the author had provided some laws
the state has for readers, they may have a better understanding of why the West
explosion happened. The readers would also more easily understand how much the
government has to do to make strong regulatory laws for the public's safety.